The Paradox of Plot • Rolling the Dice with ‘CLUE’

There is a calculated madness unfolding inside the walls of Old Town Saginaw’s Pit & Balcony Community Theatre. On stage, a familiar cast of colorful archetypes - Miss Scarlet, Professor Plum, Colonel Mustard - scurry across a shifting geometric landscape, trading rapid-fire barbs and sudden bursts of song.  At the center of it all stands the director, Todd Thomas, staring intently at a production notebook that looks less like a script and more like an advanced logistical blueprint.

They are preparing to mount 'Clue: The Musical' for a series of performances set for November 6-8 & 13-15^th, while across the region over in Midland, the Midland Center for the Arts is also set to showcase an entirely different production of the Hasbro boardgame with the national touring production of Clue: Live on Stage as part of their Broadway & Beyond series on November 14 & 15^th.

While both productions transform the beloved albeit static board game, unlike traditional theatrical murder mysteries there exist distinct differences. Clue: On Stage is a fast-paced, slapstick farce and straight play with background sound design, whereas Clue: The Musical features a full musical score, lyrics, and choreographed numbers. While: Clue: On Stage follows the screenplay of the 1985 movie starring Tim Curry (focusing on Wadsworth, Mrs. Peacock, Colonel Mustard, etc. at a dinner party), Clue: The Musical draws inspiration straight from the classic board game, transforming it into a living, breathing puzzle box by flirting with total algorithmic chaos.

The script for Clue: the Musical includes an interactive feature in which audience members randomly select cards that determine which suspect committed the murder, which weapon was used, and in what room the murder took place. Based upon the cards drawn, the mystery has 216 possible endings, for which the script provides appropriate selections of dialogue to be delivered at the show's conclusion.

Clue: On Stage, on the other hand, has a scripted, fixed storyline/ending rehearsed and performed by the actors and was adapted by Sandy Rustin that resulted in numerous national tours, whereas the Musical premiered off-Broadway back in 1997.  Clue had previously been adapted for the screen as the 1985 black comedy film of the same name and was the basis of the British television game show Cluedo, which ran from 1990 to 1993.

With Clue: the Musical Every single evening before the first note of the overture sounds, three audience members will draw cards from a giant deck, randomly selecting the killer, the murder room, and the weapon. The cards are sealed in an envelope, and the race begins. The twist? There are exactly 216 possible combinations, and the cast must be prepared to perform any single one of them at a moment's notice.

While The REVIEW was unable to secure an interview with the director of the national touring production at Midland Center, we were able to sit down with Todd Thomas, who is handling the Directorial duties for the Pit & Balcony production.

THE MATHEMATICS OF MAYHEM

To understand the sheer scale of this undertaking, one must look at the mechanics of the rehearsal room. In a typical production, an actor memorizes a linear narrative arc. They know exactly when to act surprised, when to drop a crucial clue, and precisely who to look at when the final accusation is made. For this ensemble, however, flexibility is the only absolute rule. A scene that points firmly toward Mrs. Peacock in the Conservatory with the Wrench on a Friday night might pivot entirely to Mr. Green in the Billiard Room with the Candlestick by the Saturday evening curtain.

The logistics require a radical rethinking of traditional rehearsal techniques.  It is a masterclass in mental agility, requiring the actors to maintain absolute narrative consistency while keeping a massive, invisible matrix of alternative plots alive in their heads.

When asked how he plans on handling the multiple randomized endings that create 216 possible outcomes and how he prepares the cast to keep each one of them performance ready, Thomas explains the trick is one of structure and the art of omission.

“The structure of the show stays the same, but certain pieces of dialogue and action change depending on which murderer, room and weapon the audience selects at the beginning of the evening. My job in rehearsal is to make sure the cast understands the different branches and can move into whichever version is required without the audience ever seeing the machinery behind it.” 

“That is one of the things I find most fun about the show. Eventually the cast must reach the point where those alternatives are simply part of the world they know. By performance, we want the selected solution to feel as though it was the only ending we ever intended to perform that night. The murderer’s final confession, for example, changes according to which character has been selected, while the room and weapon are incorporated into that version of the ending.”.

Unlike the straight play version, the Musical version features witty lyrics and a score that drives the investigation, so how does Thomas balance the fast-packed board game with musical numbers? “One thing I like about the score is that the music doesn’t simply stop the story so someone can sing. Much of it is carrying the investigation forward, establishing character, revealing motives, or moving us from one piece of the game to another. There are even musical cues tied directly to clues and scene changes.”

BRINGING TWO-DIMENSIONAL ICONS TO LIFE

Beyond the dizzying math of the plot, the artistic challenge lies in characterization. The suspects of Clue are iconic, but they are also fundamentally two-dimensional—literally born as flat cardboard illustrations. Everyone knows Colonel Mustard's bluster or Miss Scarlet's sultry charm, but keeping those characters engaging across a full, two-act musical requires local actors to inject genuine human energy into rigid caricatures without breaking the nostalgic spell.

The director's approach focuses on heightened reality. The characters cannot simply be cartoons; they must possess distinct motivations, even if those motivations are delightfully absurd. The music itself acts as an emotional amplifier, giving characters like the perennially nervous Mrs. White or the pompous Professor Plum a distinct sonic identity that instantly communicates their persona to the back row.

If the narrative is a puzzle, the physical stage is the board on which it must be solved. In a large-scale commercial production, automated set pieces and complex tracking systems can effortlessly whisk rooms on and off the stage. For a community theatre operating on a modest, volunteer-driven budget, creating the sprawling, multi-room labyrinth of Boddy Manor demands immense creative resourcefulness.

What are the biggest staging challenges for transitioning between rooms and how do the set designs accommodate those constant shifts with a community theatre budget and space?

“I’ve embraced this in the set design,” explains Thomas. “We have six towers that rotate and move into different configurations throughout the show, so the changing scenery becomes part of the farcical atmosphere.  The set is inventive instead of literal. The challenge is making every transition quick, clear, and entertaining enough that the audience sees the characters moving around the gameboard rather than watching furniture being moved.”

THE INTERACTIVE COMMUNITY EXPERIENCE

Ultimately, what draws audiences to this adaptation is the thrill of genuine participation. In an era dominated by passive digital entertainment, 'Clue: The Musical' offers a rare, tactile theatrical experience. The audience members are not merely spectators; they are active investigators, handed deductive forms upon entry to track clues alongside the cast. The wall between the stage and the house is completely erased, creating a shared, high-stakes game where no two performances are ever identical.

Given this fluid state, how does Thomas keep the audience actively engaged as detectives throughout the show without letting the chaos derail the storytelling?  “Audience members receive a playing form, and at specific points the house lights come up so they can record the clues they’ve been given. Near the end, they make their accusation before the solution is revealed. The show can be broad and ridiculous, but the mystery still; must make sense. The audience needs to know when something is simply comic chaos and when they’ve just been given information that matters. I think that tension is part of the fun: you’re laughing at these absurd people while at the same time trying to figure out which one of them committed the murder.”

With a cast that consists of Amariah Talley in the role of Colonel Mustard, Hayden Sparks as Mrs. White; Terri Weitzeportraying The Detective, Melony Lamar as Ms. Green, Janessa McIntosh performing Miss. Scarle, Dale Peters as Professor Plumb, Joy Howell in the role of Mrs. Peacock, and Matthew Howe as Mr. Boddy, what does Todd feel each actor brings to their role?

“We literally just had our first read-through yesterday, so I think it would be premature for me to try to define what each individual actor will ultimately bring to the production. We’ll discover that together over the next several weeks,” he states. “What I can already say is that Clue: The Musical is a true ensemble show. Every character has a very distinct personality and comic point of view, but the production depends on how those characters collide with one another. Timing, listening, reactions, and chemistry are going to be as important as what any one actor does individually. The cast also physically creates much of the changing world of Boddy Manor, so they really do have to function as a company rather than eight separate performances.”

Insofar as most people are familiar with the 1985 movie or the recent straight play (Clue: On Stage). What makes the Musical adaptation uniquely special?  “For me, the biggest difference is that this version really embraces the fact that Clue began as a game. The audience isn’t just watching somebody else solve a mystery. At the beginning of the evening, audience members select the murderer, the room, and the weapon, and those choices determine the solution we will perform that night. The script then gives the audience clues along the way so they can play the game themselves. Then you add the music, so it becomes part murder mystery, part musical comedy and part live board game. That combination is what makes this version its own thing.”

“I feel like part of Pit & Balcony's reputation is its ability to produce strong ensemble shows. In this case, as director, I’m just nudging and advising, and they are the ones bringing their commitment to the show to life.  I also love that no two audiences will have the same experience. They may see the same actors and hear the same score, but the audience itself helps determine where the evening ends. That creates a little bit of danger for the cast and, I hope, a lot of fun for everybody in the theatre.”

For Pit & Balcony Community Theatre, this production represents the core of their mission: bringing people together for an evening of collective, unpredictable joy. As the opening night approaches and the cast continues to run their randomized drills, the atmosphere in the rehearsal room is a mix of electric anticipation and acute focus. They don't know who the killer will be on opening night, or where the crime will take place, or what weapon will be used.

But as the director watches the ensemble effortlessly pivot through another simulated ending, it is entirely clear that they are ready for whatever cards the audience happens to deal.

The national Broadway touring production of Clue: On Stage takes place at Midland Center for the Arts on November 14 & 15^th. Showtimes for the Saturday evening performance are 2:00 and 7:30 PM and Sunday will feature a 2:00 PM matinee.  Tickets are available at MidlandCenter.org.

Performances of Clue: The Musical take place at Pit & Balcony on Friday – Sunday Nov. 6-8 & 13-15^th. Showtimes are 7:30 PM Nov. 6, 8 & 13 and 3:00 PM on Nov. 8.14, & 15^th. Tickets are available by phoning 989.754.6587 or visiting PitandBalconyTheatre.com.

.